Join Free! | Login 

   Popular! Books, Stories, Articles, Poetry
Where Authors and Readers come together!

Signed Bookstore | Authors | eBooks | Books | Stories | Articles | Poetry | Blogs | News | Events | Reviews | Videos | Success | Gold Members | Testimonials

Featured Authors: Linda Frank, iHelen Vandepeer, iJohn MacEachern, iKarin Fleischhaker-Griffin, iPier Tyler, iKim Glassman, iCheryl Carpinello, i
  Home > Political Science > Articles
Popular: Books, Stories, Articles, Poetry     

Mel Hathorn

  + Follow Me   

· 72 titles
· 85 Reviews
· Share with Friends!
· Save to My Library
Member Since: Apr, 2002

   Contact Author
   Read Reviews

· The Prisoner's Dilemma

· Celts and Kings

· The Castlereagh Connection

Short Stories
· Thanksgiving Day Dinner at Oliver Wight Tavern in Old Sturbridge Village

· Spanking Plato: Prologue - Chapter 3

· Sticking it to the Man

· Women in White: Parts 1-6

· Men In Black

· A Study and Discussion Guide to The Prisoner's Dilemma

· The Corporation Who Mistook Itself for a Person

· The Gymnast

· No Broccoli Tonight!!!

· The Prisoner's Dilemma (Authors note)

· Stages in the development of Social Change

· But Who's Going To Clean The Toilets?

· George Will's Unanswered Questions

· The People's Fund

· Letter to World Leaders

· An Open Letter to Connecticut Transit

· Constitutional Amendment to end Corporate Personhood

· Is Reaganomics Dead?

· A Reasonable Teaching Philosophy?

· No Taxation Without Representation

· Georgie Porgie

· The Battle Hymn of the Republic Updated" contributed

· Lament for Lost Liberties

         More poetry...
· A New Business!

· Spanking Plato

· Nobel Prize Nomination

· The First Crack in the Wall

· Are the predictions I made in The Prisoner’s Dilemma happening?

· Get The Prisoner's Dilemma free!

· Dust Cover Copy for The Prisoner's Dilemma

Mel Hathorn, click here to update your web pages on AuthorsDen.

Books by Mel Hathorn
Systems of Survival
By Mel Hathorn
Last edited: Thursday, November 09, 2006
Posted: Monday, March 18, 2002

Share    Print   Save
Recent articles by
Mel Hathorn

• How To Eliminate Corporate Personhood; Part I (Updated)
• Stages in the development of Social Change
• But Who's Going To Clean The Toilets?
• George Will's Unanswered Questions
• Letter to World Leaders
• The People's Fund
• An Open Letter to Connecticut Transit
           >> View all 39
A book review of "Systems of Survival" by Jane Jacobs.

Systems of Survival
by Jane Jacobs
Vintage Books, NYC 1992

Reviewed by Melvin Hathorn

Privatization of Education? Privatization of Corrections? Privatization of the Juvenile Justice System? These controversial questions arouse strong feelings on both sides of the issue. In Systems of Survival Jane Jacobs takes on these issues in a penetrating manner that defies the reader to pigeonhole her. This challenging book will offer thinking fodder to those who favor either position.

In Systems of Survival, she explores on a deeper level the tension that exists between the public and private sector. For she discusses two sets of opposing values or syndromes that have guided human culture throughout the centuries, the Commercial and the Guardian syndromes. It is the creative tension between these two sets of values that produce vibrant societies.

The Commercial syndrome reflects the values found in the business sector, values such as competition, efficiency, industriousness and thriftiness

The Guardian syndrome lists those values that are important to government and government agencies (which include police, the military, various regulatory agencies, etc.) Examples of these values are loyalty, respect, and hierarchy. These are the values that serve and protect society.

It's important to realize that these lists include only values specifically applicable for that syndrome. They do no include universal values such as courage, love, wisdom and patience.

She devotes a lot of time to the dangers that arise when the value systems are mixed. When commercial values are used in guardian settings or when guardian values are used in commercial settings, disaster results. She cites, among many others, the example of the New York City Transit Police who monitor the subway system.

The Department hired a consultant to study the system and suggest improvements. The consultant suggested improving the system by increasing the output of product per staff hour of work, a commercial standard. His measurement was the number of arrests per hour. Those police achieving the best productivity would be rewarded with the best assignments.

Shortly thereafter, the number of arrests increased; unfortunately, they were false arrests. It also turned out that most of the innocent were minorities who had few resources to defend themselves in court and were "persuaded" to plea bargain for reduced charges. The corruption became unraveled when the police arrested the wrong person, a New York City detective who spent hours tracking down false witnesses. His work was followed by an investigation by the District Attorney.

At this point the book shows the folly of running government like a business. But equally clear is the foolishness of applying guardian values to a commercial setting. An example of this is the funding by the World Bank of Cold War activities and the undercutting of popular unrest. The commercial values of productivity and efficiency were shortchanged and caused poor governments to go deeper into debt.

Her conclusion is that a useful definition of civilization is a reasonable guardian-commercial symbiosis, a symbiosis that is only possible through on-going dialogue and questioning. Her book is an excellent starting place for such a symbiosis.


Reader Reviews for "Systems of Survival"

Want to review or comment on this article?
Click here to login!

Need a FREE Reader Membership?
Click here for your Membership!

Reviewed by TOMSDATTAR 11/13/2002
good read

Popular Political Science Articles
  1. It’s Time to Reassess the Trump
  2. Drowning out the Drums…Staying Motivated t
  3. Why Mitt Romney Pays Only 13% and Not 35%
  4. The Opportunity Costs of Electing Ignorant
  5. What Does Your Child Know About Thomas Jef
  6. 10 Questions for All Presidential Candidat
  7. Reply to: Income Inequality Benefits Ever
  8. 600 Rabbis Sign an Endorsement for Obama
  9. Say What? How the Battle Between Individua
  10. A l’attention de Jennifer Rene « Jen » Psa

You can also search authors by alphabetical listing: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Featured Authors | New to AuthorsDen? | Add AuthorsDen to your Site
Share AD with your friends | Need Help? | About us

Problem with this page?   Report it to AuthorsDen

© AuthorsDen, Inc. All rights reserved.